Intuit is the dominant financial-technology software company behind four franchises most North Americans already use: QuickBooks (the standard small-business accounting, payroll and payments platform), TurboTax (do-it-yourself and assisted consumer tax filing), Credit Karma (a free personal-finance and credit platform monetised through lending referrals) and Mailchimp (SMB marketing automation). Its core business is selling recurring, deeply-embedded software subscriptions to ~100 million consumers and small businesses, and it throws off ~$5.5–6bn of free cash flow a year at 81% gross margins. What sets it apart is scale and lock-in: QuickBooks is the default SMB accounting system in the US and TurboTax the default DIY tax product, giving Intuit two decades of proprietary financial data and an accountant-referral network rivals struggle to replicate. The open question — and the reason the shares have halved — is whether generative AI erodes that dominance in consumer tax and bookkeeping, or whether Intuit turns AI into its next growth engine.
Intuit is a mature-growth software (application) compounder: ~$21.4bn of FY26 revenue growing 13–14%, GAAP operating margin ~27–30% (non-GAAP ~38%), 81% gross margin and ~$5.5–6bn of annual free cash flow. It sits in the Mature lifecycle bucket — profitable, self-funding, low-double-digit grower — so we value it on forward P/E, EV/EBITDA, FCF yield and the Rule of 40, not on revenue multiples. The business is a rare thing: a dominant, cash-gushing franchise that the market is currently pricing as if its moat is about to be dismantled by AI.
| Sub-signal | Reading | Score | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue trajectory | +13–14% FY26; QBO Accounting +22%, GBS +15%, TurboTax +7% | 80 | Global Business Solutions (QuickBooks + Mailchimp) is the growth engine and is accelerating; the consolidated rate is dragged only by the mature TurboTax/ProTax mix. |
| Profitability vs peers | 81% gross margin; ~38% non-GAAP op margin; net margin 22% | 85 | Top-decile software margins; margins are stable-to-expanding even through the restructuring. |
| Cash generation | FCF ~$5.5–6bn; FCF/net income ~1.0×; capex trivial (~0.6/sh) | 86 | Capital-light; cash conversion near 100% of earnings. Harder to fake than the income statement. |
| Balance-sheet health | Debt $6.9bn vs cash $6.8bn (~net-neutral); interest coverage 15.9×; current ratio 1.45 | 82 | Effectively no net leverage; distress is not a live risk. Dividend payout ~29% of earnings, comfortably covered. |
| SBC dilution (watch) | Stock-based comp ~$2bn/yr, ~9–10% of revenue | 58 | Below the 20% software red-line but material — it is the main reason non-GAAP EPS ($23.82) sits well above GAAP (~$16.4). We anchor valuation on the clean GAAP number so this real cost is not assumed away. |
Moat average ~71 — a wide but not impregnable moat. The score is deliberately below the ~85 this franchise carried two years ago because the switching-cost and pricing-power walls are being tested for the first time by a credible new attack vector (generative AI), not because the current economics have weakened.
| Product | Direct rivals | Share trajectory | Read |
|---|---|---|---|
| QuickBooks (SMB accounting) | Xero, Sage, FreshBooks, Wave (free), Zoho Books, BILL (AP/spend adjacency) | Gaining (QBO Accounting +22% YoY) | Still the US SMB standard and taking share overall — but Xero is pressing in the US and AI-native bookkeeping startups (and Xero's “Just Ask Xero” agent) target the same manual-entry work QuickBooks monetises. |
| TurboTax (consumer tax) | H&R Block, FreeTaxUSA, Cash App Taxes (free), IRS Direct File (free, expanding), generative-AI tax assistants | Defending (rev +7%, but volumes contracting) | The structural risk. Management flagged total IRS filings falling ~2m (steepest contraction since COVID) and cut the FY26 TurboTax outlook. Free government filing + AI that can explain deductions and prep answers erodes the “guided-software” premium at the low/mid end. |
| Credit Karma (personal finance) | NerdWallet, Bankrate, Experian, Credit Sesame | Cyclical | Lead-gen economics tied to the lending cycle; recovers with credit-card/personal-loan origination, soft when lenders pull back. |
| Mailchimp (SMB marketing) | Klaviyo, HubSpot, Constant Contact, Brevo | Losing | Klaviyo is winning e-commerce marketing; Mailchimp integration into the QuickBooks stack is the defence, but it is the weakest asset in the portfolio. |
Net: the franchise is gaining share where it matters most economically (QuickBooks/GBS, ~70% of the growth) while facing a genuine, non-trivial disruption threat at the consumer-tax layer. That two-sided reality is exactly why the moat sits at ~71, not 85, and it feeds directly into the §11 Bear case and the §12 thesis-invalidation triggers.
| Dimension | Reading | Score |
|---|---|---|
| ROIC / ROE | ROE 22.5%, ROA 9.5%; capital-light, high returns on incremental capital | 80 |
| Capital allocation | Consistent buybacks + a growing dividend (~29% payout); the Credit Karma and Mailchimp deals are the debated M&A — Mailchimp has underwhelmed | 66 |
| Skin in the game / SBC | Founder-adjacent culture; SBC ~9–10% of revenue is the dilution watch item | 62 |
Business Quality = 80 (High). A genuinely high-quality, cash-rich, dominant franchise. The only reasons it is not an 85+ are the SBC drag and a moat that — for the first time — has a credible line of attack rather than an unassailable position. FMP's independent health rating is B+ (ROA score 5/5, ROE 4/5, DCF 4/5), corroborating the high-quality read.
The whole story is here. Intuit has fallen ~51% year-to-date and ~62% from its July-2025 peak of $813.70 — the worst performer in the S&P 500 for much of 2026 — on fears that AI commoditises tax prep and bookkeeping. That de-rating has turned a perennial 35–45× compounder into a name trading at a discount to the broad market. The task's “if it's Expensive” branch simply does not fire: on every lens INTU is now Attractive.
| Input | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Risk-free (10-Y UST) | 4.50% | Macro state 20-Jul-2026 (“10-Y near 4.5%+”) |
| Equity risk premium | 4.50% | fixed constant |
| Risk add-on | +0.0% | Business Quality 80 (≥65) |
| Discount rate r | 9.0% | sum |
| g_near (yrs 1–5) | 10.5% | ~14% consensus EPS growth × 0.75 haircut, under the 15% secular-tech cap |
| g_term (yr 6+) | 3.0% | long-run nominal GDP cap |
| Warranted P/E | ~23.6× | two-stage; IT guardrail 33× not binding |
Actual clean (GAAP) trailing P/E = 19.3× (price $316.13 ÷ TTM GAAP EPS ~$16.4). Ratio = 19.3 ÷ 23.6 = 0.82 → Attractive/Fair edge (0.80–1.00 band). We deliberately anchor on the clean GAAP multiple, not company non-GAAP — the ~$2bn of SBC that separates the two is a real cost, so this is the conservative read. Stress it the other way and the case only strengthens: on forward non-GAAP the stock is at ~13.3× FY26 ($23.82 guide) and ~11.5× FY27 — ratios of ~0.56/0.49, deep in Attractive territory. Whichever basis you pick, INTU is cheap versus fundamentals, not just versus its own bubble-era history.
| Lens | Reading | Band |
|---|---|---|
| Warranted-multiple anchor (40%) | 19.3× vs 23.6× warranted → 0.82 | Attractive/Fair edge |
| Sector median (20%) | IT sector ~26–28× forward; INTU ~13× forward non-GAAP | Well below — Attractive |
| Own 5-yr history decile (15%) | Historically 35–45× fwd non-GAAP; now ~13× — bottom decile, near-unprecedented | Attractive (extreme) |
| PEG (10%) | Trailing PEG 0.57; forward PEG ~1.4–1.5 | Fair-to-Attractive |
| Analyst consensus (15%) | Price $316 vs mean target $456 (33 analysts), median $430 | Below — but targets falling fast |
Framing: the core in-production franchise justifies most of the ~$316 price on its own; the AI-offence and mid-market options are close to free at today's multiple. This is a tilt (+a few points), and the reason to keep watching — not a reason the stock is cheap. It is already cheap on the core.
Analyst target caveat (important): the $456 mean is stale and decaying — last-quarter average $397, and the last-month average is just $337 (3 analysts), with TD Cowen cutting to Hold on 28 Jul. So the “44% upside to consensus” overstates the live signal; the fresh consensus is nearer $337 (~7% above spot). We weight the anchor and cash yield above the analyst target for exactly this reason.
Valuation = 76 (Attractive/Fair edge). Cheap on the anchor, the cash yield, the sector cross-read and its own history — but scored at the lower end of Attractive (not 85+) because the cheapness is earned: there is a real, unresolved reason (AI disruption of consumer tax) the market is demanding a discount. This is a margin-of-safety story, not a no-brainer.
Intuit's dominant external driver is the AI & Productivity Revolution (a Dominance-4/HIGH enduring driver in the 30-Jul macro) — and for INTU it is genuinely two-sided, which is why the driver score is deliberately mid-band rather than a “secular tailwind.”
| Horizon | Driver read | Signal |
|---|---|---|
| Short (1–3 mo) | AI narrative is a net overhang — every AI-tax or AI-bookkeeping headline pressures the stock; the offence case is unproven quarter-to-quarter. | Neutral / mild headwind |
| Medium (6–12 mo) | Balance tips on evidence: does Intuit Assist lift ARPU and retention, or does Direct File + free AI keep bleeding TurboTax? Restructuring re-tools the org around AI. | Neutral (contested) |
| Long (3–5 yr) | If Intuit becomes the AI-native financial “operating system” for SMBs and consumers, AI is a durable tailwind — but terminal disruption of the tax franchise is a real tail. Un-resolvable today. | Contested tailwind |
Amplification note: Driver score 54 — above the 50 threshold that keeps the Fundamental entry group open, but deliberately below 65, so it does not amplify the Long BUY to STRONG BUY. That is the correct call: you cannot back the truck up on a name whose single most important driver is a coin-flip between existential threat and secular tailwind. The driver is the reason to own it and the reason to size it at half.
Per the 30-Jul MacroDriver (regime: Stagflation-lite — energy re-armed, policy-tight, narrow/contested/tape-unconfirmed), Technology / XLK reads Neutral (short) / Underperform (medium) / Outperform (long). Net pressure is Neutral-to-mild-Headwind over the medium horizon (rate + concentration drag) turning to a secular AI/software tailwind long. Because the position leans into near-term sector weakness ahead of the long-horizon Outperform, we tag the stance Contrarian (buying a beaten-down quality name against a mild sector headwind), conviction 55.
Source: sector-map (XLK) · Macro report 2026-07-30
Timing is the weak pillar and the reason Short is a HOLD. The primary (monthly/weekly) trend is still down — price sits far below the daily SMA200 ($468) after a ~62% peak-to-trough collapse — while a tactical recovery is underway on the daily (reclaimed the 20/50-DMA, MACD turned positive). This is textbook “counter-trend bounce inside a secular downtrend”: constructive, but not yet a confirmed reversal.
| Component | Reading | Score |
|---|---|---|
| MTF trend (30%) | Monthly + weekly downtrend (RSI 33/39, oversold); daily recovering (RSI 59, above 20/50-DMA); hourly weakening | ~39 |
| Risk-reward (20%) | Price $316; support ~$302/$290 (~1.6 ATR); resistance $336 → $363 → $412. 52-wk range position ~12% (beaten down) | ~55 |
| Macro overlay (10%) | Tech = low macro sensitivity; XLK Neutral(S)/Underperform(M) is a mild headwind near-term | ~45 |
| Sentiment (20%) | TD Cowen downgrade (28 Jul); analyst targets cut hard ($563→$397→$337); but +18% 1-month recovery | ~35 |
| Catalyst (20%) | Q4/FY26 earnings ~late Aug (restructuring charge + TurboTax outlook) — near-term skew negative per Street | ~55 |
Relative strength: catastrophic on 3/6/12-month windows (down ~50% YTD, massively lagging SPY and XLK); improving only on the 1-month (+18% off the low). Position-risk: the stock is +25% off its $252.84 low — chasing here, below the 200-DMA and into an earnings catalyst with a negative near-term skew, is poor risk-reward for a Short entry. Timing = 46 (Neutral). The daily reclaim happened on only ~1.08× volume (below the 1.5× confirmation bar), so we treat the Technical entry group as not yet met — buy the confirmation (a >1.5×-volume daily close over ~$336, or a tested higher low off $290–$300), not the bounce.
| Date | Event | Impact | Forecast | Previous | Relevant? | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ~2026-08-20 (est) | INTU Q4/FY26 earnings | High | Non-GAAP EPS $3.56–3.62; rev +11–12% | Q4 FY25: $1.35 GAAP | ⚠ Beyond 14d | The dominant catalyst: FY27 guide, TurboTax/GBS trajectory, ~$300–340m restructuring charge lands in this quarter. |
| 2026-07-31 | Core PCE (Jun) | High | — | — | ⚠ Medium | Low direct sensitivity (tech), but sets the rate/discount-rate backdrop for long-duration equities. |
| 2026-08-01 | Tariff deadline | High | — | — | · Low | Macro-regime risk; little direct INTU exposure (domestic software). |
| Date | Event | Actual | Forecast | Surprise | Impact |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-07-28 | TD Cowen downgrade | Hold (from Buy) | — | Negative | Near-term catalyst path seen skewing negative; capped the recovery. |
| 2026-05-20 | Q3/FY26 print + 17% layoff | Beat + raise, softer TurboTax | In line | Mixed | Beat-and-raise but shares fell — the market focused on the TurboTax cut and AI narrative, not the headline beat. |
Tech is a low-macro-sensitivity sector, so the swing factor is the idiosyncratic Q4/FY26 print (~late Aug), which sits just beyond the 14-day window — hence no earnings gate today, and the next scheduled update (14 Aug) precedes it. The Street's near-term skew is cautious (TD Cowen), so we prefer to enter on post-print confirmation rather than ahead of it.
| Timeframe | Trend | Direction | RSI | MACD | Key S/R | Breakout | Vol |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly | Downtrend ↓ | Bearish | 32.6 | −, deep | S: $339 R: $675 | Support break | 1.7× |
| Weekly | Downtrend ↓ | Bearish | 38.6 | −, hist rising | S: $253 R: $683 | Support break | 1.0× |
| Daily | Recovering ↑ | Neutral-Bull | 58.9 | +, rising | S: $302 R: $363 | Resist. breakout | 1.1× |
| Hourly | Weakening → | Neutral | 52.2 | ~flat | S: $307 R: $318 | — | 0.4× |
| 15-min | Recovering ↑ | Neutral | 59.5 | +, small | S: $310 R: $317 | Resist. breakout | 0.1× |
| Confluence: Bearish (secular) with a live tactical recovery · MTF Score 39 | |||||||
Monthly and weekly remain in clear downtrends with oversold RSI (33/39) — the primary trend is still down and price is far below the 200-DMA ($468). The daily has turned constructive: price reclaimed the 20/50-DMA, MACD crossed positive, and a resistance breakout is flagged — but on only ~1.08× volume, below the 1.5× conviction bar. Read together: a genuine bounce off the $252.84 low that has not yet earned ‘trend reversal’ status. Key levels: support $302 / $290 (50-DMA); resistance $336 then $363. The Short stays HOLD until the daily confirms on volume or a higher low is tested.
Six-month daily: the collapse to $252.84 (Jun) and the ~25% recovery to $316. The 50-DMA (orange) was reclaimed in July; $336 is the next resistance, $290/$252 the supports.
Intuit Assist / agentic ‘done-for-you’ features prove ARPU-accretive, TurboTax stabilises post-Direct-File-scare, and QuickBooks/GBS keeps compounding mid-teens. FY27 non-GAAP EPS ~$27+ re-rates from ~13× toward ~20–22× forward. ~+58% from spot. The market re-learns that AI is Intuit's offence, not just its threat.
AI fears stabilise without resolving; GBS/QuickBooks compound mid-teens, TurboTax holds roughly flat, and the multiple normalises modestly from ~13× to ~17× forward non-GAAP ($23.82 FY26 guide). ~$400 is ~+27% from spot — a re-rating toward ‘quality-compounder-with-an-asterisk,’ not back to the 35× bubble. Most-probable path.
The disruption is real: IRS Direct File + free AI tax prep visibly erode TurboTax volumes and pricing, AI bookkeeping agents commoditise QuickBooks data-entry, and consolidated growth decelerates to high-single-digits. The multiple stays stuck near ~10× and the stock retests its $252.84 low. ~−21% from spot. This is the thesis-invalidation scenario — watch QBO Accounting growth and TurboTax volumes.
Probability-weighted fair value ≈ $395 (0.55×$400 + 0.25×$500 + 0.20×$250) — ~+25% above the $316.13 spot, with the Bear only ~21% below. That asymmetry (roughly 2.5:1 reward-to-risk into the weighted mean, with a Bear that merely retests a level already visited) is the core of the Medium/Long BUY. The Short stays HOLD purely on timing.
Forecast: Fundamental group is MET now — a valid Half-Size starter/scale-in for a 6–12mo+ horizon. The Technical group likely resolves around the ~late-Aug Q4/FY26 print: a >1.5×-volume daily close over ~$336 (or a confirmed higher low off $290–$300) opens a second path and would take conviction to Full-Size. Buy the confirmation for a Short entry; the Fundamental case is already open for Medium/Long.
Forecast: No exit trigger is live; the stop ($250) sits ~21% below spot and would only arm on a full retest of the low. The first thing to break the thesis would be QuickBooks/GBS deceleration, not the tax noise — that is what to watch.
Position sizing not computed — no portfolio allocation or role was specified for this run. The Conviction Ladder reads Half-Size (one entry path open), which is the natural expression of ‘cheap and high-quality, but timing-unconfirmed with a live AI-disruption tail.’
{
"ticker": "INTU",
"date": "2026-07-31",
"version": "v6",
"company": "Intuit Inc.",
"currency": "USD",
"brand": "",
"exchange": "NASDAQ",
"exchange_ticker": "NASDAQ:INTU",
"isin": "US4612021034",
"api_ticker": "INTU",
"analysis_status": "starting",
"finder_ticker": "INTU",
"finder_exchange": "NASDAQ",
"lifecycle_stage": "mature",
"price_at_rating": 316.13,
"signal_short": "HOLD",
"signal_medium": "BUY",
"signal_long": "BUY",
"primary_signal": "BUY",
"short_hold_reason": "technical_pending",
"short_entry_confirmed": false,
"short_cap_reason": "Short base signal was BUY (cheap, High-Quality) but capped to HOLD: only the Fundamental entry group is met. Technical unmet (daily reclaimed 50-DMA on sub-1.5x volume, still below 200-DMA, monthly/weekly downtrend); Catalyst unmet (earnings beyond window, negative near-term skew). Buy on confirmation: >1.5x-volume daily close over ~$336, or a tested higher low off $290-300.",
"quality_score": 80,
"valuation_score": 76,
"timing_score": 46,
"driver_score": 54,
"overall_confidence": 57,
"economic_alignment_stance": "Contrarian",
"economic_alignment_conviction": 55,
"economic_alignment_pressure": "Neutral-to-mild-Headwind (medium)",
"economic_alignment_source": "sector-map",
"macro_report_date": "2026-07-30",
"warranted_multiple": 23.6,
"actual_multiple": 19.3,
"val_multiple_basis": "clean (GAAP) trailing P/E",
"warranted_ratio": 0.82,
"val_band": "attractive",
"discount_rate_r": 0.09,
"risk_free_10y": 0.045,
"g_near": 0.105,
"g_term": 0.03,
"nonop_pct_of_net_income": -1,
"clean_pe": 19.3,
"clean_peg": 1.4,
"fwd_pe_nongaap_fy26": 13.3,
"fwd_pe_nongaap_fy27": 11.5,
"competitive_share_trajectory": "mixed",
"competitive_threat_level": "elevated",
"rule_of_40": 40,
"fcf_yield_pct": 7.0,
"fair_value_est": 395,
"stop_loss": 250,
"target_price": 400,
"scenario_base_target": 400,
"scenario_bull_target": 500,
"scenario_bear_target": 250,
"scenario_base_prob": 55,
"scenario_bull_prob": 25,
"scenario_bear_prob": 20,
"entry_groups_met": 1,
"entry_conviction": "Half-Size",
"exit_groups_live": 0,
"exit_action": "Hold",
"hard_gate_state": "caution",
"gates_triggered": [],
"do_not_buy_triggers": [],
"analyst_consensus_target": 456.47,
"analyst_consensus_target_fresh_1m": 337.33,
"analyst_target_high": 921.0,
"analyst_target_low": 250.0,
"analyst_bullish_pct": 67,
"analyst_coverage_count": 33,
"next_update_date": "2026-08-14",
"next_update_basis": "default +14d (Q4/FY26 earnings ~late Aug beyond window; restructuring charge + TurboTax/FY27 guide the key catalysts then)"
}
Anchored on the clean GAAP trailing P/E for continuity with the 16-Jul report and to avoid non-GAAP flattery; the forward non-GAAP cross-check (~13×) only strengthens the Attractive read.