Alimentation Couche-Tard is one of the world's largest operators of convenience stores and fuel forecourts, running roughly 17,000 sites across North America, Europe and Asia under the Circle K, Couche-Tard, Holiday and Ingo banners. Its core business is simple and cash-generative: sell high-margin merchandise (snacks, drinks, tobacco, fresh food) and road-transport fuel to millions of daily customers, and earn a spread on both. What sets it apart is scale and a 40-year record as a disciplined serial acquirer — it has repeatedly bought regional chains and lifted their margins onto its own operating template, compounding earnings faster than the industry. It reports in US dollars but is listed and priced in Canadian dollars on the TSX. For a reader, think of it as a defensive, high-return-on-equity retail compounder whose edge is buying and running convenience networks better than almost anyone.
Lifecycle & sector: Consumer Staples — convenience retail + fuel. Lifecycle stage Cash Cow / mature compounder: single-digit organic revenue growth, high and stable profitability, capital returned via buybacks and a growing dividend, growth topped up by bolt-on M&A. We score it on ROE/ROIC, FCF, margin stability, same-store sales and capital-allocation discipline — the mature/cash-cow lens — not on hyper-growth metrics.
| Sub-signal | ATD value | Sector context | Score | Read |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Return on Equity | 20.1% | Staples-retail median ~15% | 88 | Excellent — top-quartile; FMP ROE sub-score 5/5 |
| Return on Assets | 7.1% | Retail median ~5-6% | 75 | Above peers — efficient asset use for a fuel/retail network |
| Same-store merchandise (US) | +3.4% | Healthy retail comp 3-5% | 78 | Positive US comps; Europe +1.1%, Canada -0.9% (soft spot) |
| Operating margin | 9.2% | Convenience 8-12% | 70 | In-range; fuel-margin uplift this year flatters it |
| FCF generation | ~C$2.36B | Consistent, funds M&A + buybacks | 78 | Strong cash conversion — the engine of the roll-up |
| Balance sheet | Net debt/EBITDA ~1.9x | <2.0x healthy for retail | 66 | Manageable but D/E 75.9% (FMP D/E sub-score 2/5 — the one drag), leaves M&A headroom |
Moat average ≈ 62. The durable edge is cost advantage / scale (fuel procurement + network density) and the integration playbook, not customer lock-in — convenience is a location-and-habit business, so switching costs are inherently modest, which is why the score is honest at 55 rather than inflated.
| Rival | Threat type | Share trajectory (ATD vs rival) | Moat-erosion vector |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7-Eleven / Seven & i | Direct #1 by US store count (~12,232 vs ATD/Circle K ~6,850) | ATD stable / mildly pressured | Post-failed-bid, 7-Eleven plans ~1,300 large-format food-focused stores by 2030 — attacks ATD's fresh-food growth lane |
| Casey's (CASY) | Fast-growing Midwest food-forward operator (~2,831 stores) | ATD stable, Casey's gaining footprint | Aggressive new-store + prepared-food expansion in overlapping geographies |
| Murphy USA (MUSA) | Low-cost, fuel-led, Walmart-adjacent (~1,800 stores) | ATD stable | Price competition at the pump pressures fuel margin at the margin |
| Parkland | Canadian fuel/convenience peer | ATD stable | Regional Canadian competition; less of a US threat |
ROIC comfortably above cost of capital (ROE 20%, ROA 7% on a modestly-levered balance sheet) puts ATD in the top quartile of retail capital-efficiency. Capital allocation is the crown jewel: a 40-year record of accretive acquisitions (Circle K, Holiday, Statoil/Ingo, CST, Total's European sites) bought at reasonable multiples and integrated onto ATD's operating template, complemented by steady buybacks and a low-payout (17.5%) growing dividend. Management skin-in-the-game is solid (founder-influenced board, insider ownership). The one blemish is the Seven & i saga — an ambitious but ultimately withdrawn US$47B mega-bid (Jul 2025) that consumed management attention; the discipline to walk away rather than overpay is, on balance, a capital-allocation positive.
ATD is Fair — not cheap, not expensive. The warranted-multiple anchor is the arbiter; relative lenses order it within that band.
Earnings-quality decomposition (step 7b): Q4 FY26 GAAP EPS was US$0.94 but included a ~US$196M one-off gain from US interchange (card-network) litigation; adjusted Q4 EPS was US$0.73. Across FY26, GAAP net income US$3.1B vs adjusted US$2.9B — the non-operating item is ~6.5% of FY net income (Q4 alone 22.7%). Below the 15% annual distortion threshold, but we still score off the adjusted figure: clean P/E 20.54× (US$3.10 → C$4.41), which is higher (less attractive) than the reported 18.89×. Scoring off the clean number is the conservative, honest choice.
| Multiple | ATD | Context | Read |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clean P/E (adjusted) | 20.54× | vs warranted 19.34× | Fair (1.06×) |
| Reported P/E (TTM) | 18.89× | flattered by the one-off gain | Attractive/Fair edge |
| Forward P/E | 17.5× | on C$5.17 fwd EPS | Below warranted — forward-attractive |
| EV/EBITDA | 14.1× | quality-retail 12-15× | Fair |
| PEG (clean) | 2.05 | on ~10% growth | Full — quality premium |
| Price/Book | 3.6× | high ROE justifies >1 | Fair for 20% ROE |
Implied-growth read: at C$90.49 the market embeds roughly 8-9% long-run growth; management guides >10% organic EPS and consensus ~10%. So the price embeds slightly less growth than the fundamentals support — a modest positive, consistent with the Fair (not Expensive) verdict and the ~13% upside to the analyst mean.
| Analyst consensus (CAD) | Value | vs price C$90.49 |
|---|---|---|
| Mean target | C$102.00 | +12.7% |
| Median target | C$102.65 | +13.4% |
| High / Low | C$108.69 / C$89.74 | +20% / -0.8% |
| Coverage / grades | 18 analysts · 6 Strong Buy, 8 Buy, 5 Hold, 0 Sell | 74% bullish (consensus BUY, 1.84) |
| FMP health rating | B+ (overall 3/5) | ROE 5/5, ROA 4/5, D/E 2/5 (the leverage drag) |
Analyst target signal ~65 (meaningful ~13% upside to consensus); grades consensus ~72 (solid buy with some holds). Blended with the anchor's 40% weight, Valuation lands 56 — lower-half Fair.
Primary driver — a composite of three forces: (1) merchandise/staples demand (defensive, steady — trade-down flows toward convenience in a soft consumer), (2) fuel margins (the near-term swing factor), and (3) the M&A roll-up strategy (the structural growth lever). We score the composite, weighting fuel margin and M&A as the movable parts.
| Horizon | Read | Detail & source |
|---|---|---|
| Historical (25%) | Tailwind | Fuel margins expanded sharply in FY26 (US road-fuel margin 52.44¢/gal, +9.17¢ YoY); merchandise comps positive; 40-yr accretive-M&A record. (Q4/FY26 press release, 22 Jun 2026) |
| Current (50%) | Tailwind — but elevated & mean-reverting | Retail fuel margin is at a cyclically high level (a level, not a fresh uptrend), which flatters current earnings and is the main normalisation risk. Merchandise demand steady. M&A: the transformational leg took a real hit (Seven & i withdrawn 16 Jul 2025), leaving bolt-on as the path. |
| Forward (25%) | Neutral-to-Tailwind | Management reaffirmed >10% organic EPS growth for FY27 (trends similar to Q4). Offsets: fuel-margin normalisation risk + a contracting US consumer-credit read. |
Fuel-retailer note (not a producer): ATD is a fuel retailer, so — unlike a miner or E&P — the commodity price-trend overlay works in reverse: falling wholesale crude typically expands retail fuel margin (the pump price lags the wholesale drop). So a soft oil tape is often a tailwind here, not a headwind. We therefore do not apply a producer-style downtrend cap.
Amplification role: the score is 64 — Neutral, at the very top of the band but below the 65 amplification bar. This is deliberate and honest: fuel margins are a genuine tailwind but sit at an elevated, mean-reverting level, and the transformational-M&A leg is impaired — a borderline composite, not a clean ≥65 tailwind. So the driver is not amplification-eligible; the base BUY/HOLD stands unamplified. It does not change the three fundamental pillar scores.
The 9 Jul macro report reads a 'Higher-for-Longer / Stagflation-lite' regime and rates Consumer Staples (XLP) N / O / N — a mild medium-term Outperform as capital rotates defensive. ATD is a defensive staple with a fuel-margin kicker, so the pressure is a mild Tailwind (Trend-Following) medium-term and Neutral short-term. Because the pressure is only mild and the driver sits at 64 (below the 65 amplification bar), with the base signal a HOLD at short/medium (which never amplifies) and a BUY at long, the pressure leaves the base signals unchanged — no STRONG-BUY amplification.
Source: sector-map (Consumer Staples / XLP) · Macro report 2026-07-09
The timing pillar answers 'is now a good moment to act?' — separately from whether ATD is a good business (it is) or fairly priced (it is). The answer here: the trend is up but the entry is extended.
| Sub-signal | Read | Score |
|---|---|---|
| MTF trend (30%) | Monthly/weekly/daily up; intraday pullback → confluence 68 | 68 |
| Risk-reward / position-risk (20%) | Overbought, wide stop, near resistance not support | 45 |
| Relative strength | Outperforming SPY & XLP over 1m/3m post-earnings (strong) | 78 |
| Macro overlay (10%, low-sensitivity sector) | Higher-for-longer neutral-to-mild-positive for a defensive staple | 58 |
| Sentiment | Consensus BUY (74% bullish); post-beat tone positive — but firm-level grade dates unavailable (data gap) | 66 |
| Catalyst layer | No catalyst in 30 days (next earnings 8 Sep) — calm calendar (clustering 70) | 70 |
Weighted timing ≈ 52 — Neutral. The tension is real and worth stating plainly: this is a great business in a strong uptrend that you'd rather buy 6-9% lower. The higher-timeframe strength supports the medium/long BUY; the overbought daily and wide stop are why the short-term signal is HOLD. Relative strength is a genuine positive — ATD is leading its sector — but relative strength near a 52-week high is momentum, not a value entry.
| Date | Event | Impact | Forecast | Previous | Relevant? | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-07-14 | Core CPI YoY (Jun) | Medium | 2.9% | 2.9% | ⚠️ Medium | Staples: food-inflation & consumer-spending read; sticky core keeps the higher-for-longer tape |
| 2026-07-16 | Retail Sales (Jun) | Medium | +0.3% | — | ⚠️ Medium | Consumer-spending signal for merchandise comps |
| 2026-07-17 | Michigan Sentiment (Jul) | Low | 50.4 | — | — Low | Confidence read; low direct impact on a defensive name |
| 2026-09-08 | ATD Q1 FY27 earnings | High | — | — | ✅ Yes | The next company-specific catalyst — out of the 14-day window |
| Date | Event | Actual | Forecast | Surprise | Impact |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-07-09 | Initial Jobless Claims | 215K | 218K | -1.4% (below) | Neutral: labour still firm, supports traffic |
| 2026-07-08 | Consumer Credit (May) | -0.18 | +17.1 | -101% (below) | Mild negative: consumer credit contracting — watch discretionary spend, ATD is defensive |
| 2026-07-09 | Existing Home Sales (Jun) | 4.09M | 4.2M | -2.6% (below) | Neutral for ATD (housing, not convenience) |
ATD is a low-macro-sensitivity Consumer-Staples name, so no upcoming release is a hard trigger. The one to note is Jun CPI (14 Jul): sticky food inflation squeezes merchandise basket size but also lets ATD pass through price. Contracting consumer credit is a mild yellow flag for discretionary spend, but a convenience/fuel staple is where trade-down flows land, not away from. No high-impact, ATD-specific event inside 3 trading days, so no WAIT-for-event override.
| Timeframe | Trend | Direction | RSI | MACD | Key S/R | Breakout | Vol |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly | Uptrend ↑ | Bullish | 63.0 | +, rising | S: 63.3 R: 87.3 | Resistance breakout | 0.3x |
| Weekly | Uptrend ↑ | Bullish | 64.0 | +, rising | S: 72.0 R: 95.15 | Resistance breakout | 1.1x |
| Daily | Strong Up ↑ | Bullish (overbought) | 70.7 | +, flattening | S: 82.7 R: 95.15 | Resistance breakout | 1.3x |
| Hourly | Downtrend ↓ | Bearish | 36.4 | -, falling | S: 89.1 R: 93.9 | Support breakdown | 1.3x |
| 15-min | Downtrend ↓ | Bearish | 30.0 | -, basing | S: 90.5 R: 93.6 | Support breakdown | 4.0x |
| Confluence: Bullish (higher-TF) with a short-term pullback · MTF Score 68 | |||||||
Monthly, weekly and daily trends are all up — ATD broke to a fresh high on the 22 Jun earnings gap and holds well above its rising 200-day (77.6) and 50-day (82.7) averages. The caveat is the daily RSI at 70.7 (overbought) and the intraday timeframes (hourly/15-min) rolling over, which is a textbook short-term pullback inside a larger uptrend. That is why the short-term signal is HOLD: the trend is your friend for the medium/long hold, but chasing at C$90+ into an overbought daily leaves you buying near resistance (95.15) rather than at the 82-85 support shelf.
ATD.TO 6-month daily (C$). The 22 Jun earnings gap from ~82 to ~92 on 5x volume drives the current setup; price now consolidates just under the 95.15 high, well above the rising 50- and 200-day averages. Support shelf 82-85; fair value ~C$85.
Fuel margins hold near current elevated levels (US 52c/gal) rather than normalising, US merchandise comps stay +3-4%, and ATD deploys its balance sheet into one or more accretive bolt-on acquisitions now that the Seven & i mega-deal is off the table. Multiple re-rates toward ~19x forward on renewed compounding confidence. ~C$115 is above the C$108.69 high analyst target — it needs both the margin and the M&A leg to fire.
The company delivers its guided >10% organic EPS growth, fuel margins ease modestly but stay healthy, merchandise comps stay positive, and the multiple holds around 17.5x forward. That lands ~C$102 — in line with the C$102 analyst mean/median. This is the probability-weighted centre of gravity: a quality compounder growing into a fair multiple.
Fuel margins normalise back toward mid-cycle (a real risk from today's elevated ~52c/gal), the US consumer weakens further (contracting consumer credit), and share pressure builds as 7-Eleven rolls out ~1,300 large-format food stores by 2030 and Casey's keeps expanding. Merchandise comps stall, the multiple de-rates toward ~15x, and price retraces to the rising 200-day near C$77. Competitive/margin-normalisation is the live downside trigger.
Forecast: Fundamental group: FORECAST ~ price needs to fall ~6% to C$85, OR one to two quarters of earnings growth to lift fair value to today's price — CONFIDENCE Moderate; a market pullback or a fuel-margin scare could open it faster. Technical group: FORECAST the overbought daily RSI (70.7, easing ~1-2 pts/week on a flat tape) would reach the ≤65 entry band in ~3-4 weeks, OR immediately on a pullback to the 82-85 shelf — CONFIDENCE Moderate. Catalyst group: catalyst-dependent — next window is the 8 Sep Q1 print. Net: no entry path is open today (Wait); the most likely first opening is a technical pullback into the 82-85 support shelf.
Forecast: Stop-loss (C$82): Unlikely in the next 4-6 weeks — price C$90.49 is ~9% above it and the 50/200-day are rising; would need a broad market selloff or a fuel-margin scare. Thesis invalidation: not live — comps positive, guidance reaffirmed; watch the Sep quarter for fuel-margin normalisation. Profit-target: not live — price below the C$108 zone and RSI would need to be >70 there too.
What you're risking: you'd be buying an overbought daily (RSI 70.7) ~5% below the 52-week high and ~6% above our C$85 fair value — none of the three entry groups is met. The nearest logical stop is C$82 (~9% down); the bear path is C$76 (~16% down) if fuel margins normalise and share pressure bites. You collect a slim ~1% dividend while you wait.
What you're gaining: immediate exposure to a high-ROE (20%) compounder guiding >10% organic EPS growth, with ~13% base-case upside to the C$102 analyst mean and ~27% to the bull case, plus the free optionality of accretive bolt-on M&A now that the mega-deal is off. Risk-reward from here is roughly 1.5:1 to base, better to bull.
Read: the business is a clear BUY-quality hold, but acting at C$90.49 is buying near resistance into an overbought tape. Waiting for the 82-85 support shelf materially improves the deal — this is an accumulate-on-weakness, not a chase-now.
What you're giving up: the base-case run to C$102 (~13%), the bull optionality to C$115 (~27%), the guided >10% EPS growth compounding, and the M&A free option. At C$90.49 you'd be selling roughly at fair-plus (price is above our C$85 trailing fair value but below the C$102 forward analyst mean) — not obviously below fair value.
What you're protecting: capital against the C$76 bear (fuel-margin normalisation + competitive share loss) and the near-term overbought unwind. But no exit rule is actually triggered right now — the stop is 9% away, guidance is intact, comps are positive.
Read: there is no mechanical reason to sell. For a holder this is a hold; for a non-holder it is an accumulate-on-weakness zone, not a sell.
No risk budget or portfolio role was specified for this run, so position sizing is not computed. For reference: the §12 Conviction Ladder reads Wait (0 of 3 entry groups met) — there is no entry edge at C$90.49, so the sizing guidance is 'wait for a path to open' rather than a percentage. The reachable first entry is a pullback into the C$82-85 support shelf. Volatility context: daily ATR ≈ C$2.06 (~2.3% of price), beta 0.73 (defensive, ~27% less volatile than the market), 52-week range C$67.9-95.15. Specify your allocation and role for sizing math.
{
"ticker": "ATD.TO",
"company": "Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc.",
"currency": "CAD",
"date": "2026-07-10",
"version": "v6",
"exchange": "TSX",
"exchange_ticker": "TSX:ATD",
"isin": "CA01626P1484",
"api_ticker": "ATD.TO",
"price_at_rating": 90.49,
"signal_short": "HOLD",
"signal_medium": "HOLD",
"signal_long": "BUY",
"primary_signal": "HOLD",
"quality_score": 82,
"lifecycle_stage": "cash cow / mature compounder",
"quality_detail": {
"industry_benchmark_name": "Same-Store Sales + Inventory/Asset Turns (Retail)",
"industry_benchmark_value": "US comps +3.4%",
"industry_benchmark_score": 80,
"moat_score": 70,
"roic_percentile_vs_peers": 78,
"capital_allocation": 82,
"management_skin_in_game": 72
},
"valuation_score": 56,
"valuation_detail": {
"fcf_yield": 2.66,
"implied_growth_rate": 8.5,
"consensus_growth_rate": 10.0,
"historical_valuation_decile": 6
},
"warranted_multiple": 19.34,
"actual_multiple": 20.54,
"val_multiple_basis": "clean (adjusted) P/E, CAD",
"discount_rate_r": 0.0906,
"risk_free_10y": 0.0456,
"g_near": 0.06,
"g_term": 0.03,
"warranted_ratio": 1.06,
"val_band": "fair",
"timing_score": 52,
"timing_detail": {
"mtf_confluence": 68,
"risk_reward_score": 45,
"relative_strength_vs_spy": 8.0,
"relative_strength_vs_sector": 6.0,
"catalyst_clustering_score": 70,
"dynamic_macro_weight": 0.1
},
"driver_score": 64,
"driver_commodity_trend": "N/A \u2014 fuel-retailer margin (not producer). Retail fuel margin elevated (US 52.44c/gal, +9.17c YoY); a falling wholesale crude typically EXPANDS retail margin, the opposite of a producer.",
"economic_alignment_stance": "Trend-Following",
"economic_alignment_conviction": 60,
"economic_alignment_pressure": "Tailwind",
"economic_alignment_source": "sector-map",
"macro_report_date": "2026-07-09",
"overall_confidence": 62,
"nonop_pct_of_net_income": 6.5,
"clean_pe": 20.54,
"clean_peg": 2.05,
"competitive_share_trajectory": "stable",
"competitive_threat_level": "elevated",
"fair_value_est": 85.29,
"stop_loss": 82.0,
"target_price": 102.0,
"analyst_consensus_target": 102.0,
"analyst_target_high": 108.69,
"analyst_target_low": 89.74,
"analyst_target_upside_pct": 12.7,
"analyst_grades_consensus": "buy",
"analyst_bullish_pct": 74,
"analyst_coverage_count": 18,
"fmp_rating": "B+",
"fmp_overall_score": 3,
"recent_upgrades_30d": null,
"recent_downgrades_30d": null,
"scenario_base_target": 102,
"scenario_bull_target": 115,
"scenario_bear_target": 76,
"entry_groups_met": 0,
"entry_conviction": "Wait",
"exit_groups_live": 0,
"exit_action": "Hold",
"hard_gate_state": "clear",
"gates_triggered": [],
"gates_caution": [],
"do_not_buy_triggers": [],
"user_horizon": null,
"user_allocation_pct": null,
"portfolio_role": null,
"next_update_date": "2026-07-24",
"next_update_basis": "default +14d (no impactful event; earnings 2026-09-08 out of window)",
"analysis_status": "starting",
"finder_ticker": "ATD.TO",
"finder_exchange": "\ud83c\udde8\ud83c\udde6 TSX"
}
ATD.TO rated HOLD (Short) / HOLD (Medium) / BUY (Long) at C$90.49 on 10 Jul 2026 — a high-quality, fairly-priced convenience-retail compounder that is simply extended after its 22 Jun earnings gap. The base Decision Matrix puts High Quality + Fair Valuation + Neutral Timing on the HOLD row (watch for a valuation entry); only the long horizon, where Quality dominates, lifts to BUY. All hard gates clear, no Do-Not-Buy trigger. Entry conviction: Wait (0/3) — good business, no entry edge now. First report on the name (finder promotion, status 'Starting').